
Above: THE UNINSURED - Nemsley, 14, walked through Northwest Haiti Christian Mission's clinic on crutches in October, a week after visiting surgeons had to amputate his lower right leg because of cancer. If Nemsley had regular access to good health care, as most of us do in the United States, he probably would still have his leg.
I spend much of my time photographing in a country where health insurance is a non-issue because there is no such thing. In Haiti, virtually no one has anything resembling health coverage -- if you have the money, you pay a doctor; if you don't have the money, you just don't get better. Or perhaps you die.
Haiti's derelict economy affects doctors as much as it affects patients: Namely, there are hardly any doctors. Even if a Haitian had the money to pay for a specialized surgery, for example, there is a strong chance he would have to leave the country to find a doctor to perform it. A Haitian doctor there told me recently there is one pediatric surgeon in the entire nation.
None of this is new, of course. It's been that way for decades. But it's been on my mind lately as America watches what could potentially be the final days of the debate over health care reform on Capital Hill.
For me, the case for health care reform has always seemed entirely without any need for defense. It should be a no-brainer.
Full disclosure here: I have a bias. But it's not of the "conservative" or "liberal" sort. My bias is that I call two places home -- one place is Haiti, where I have seen firsthand the devastating effects of poor health care, and the other place is Kentucky. In Kentucky, nearly 700,000 people are uninsured, 16 percent of the population and one of the highest rates in the United States (per the Census Bureau).
That fact should be unacceptable to anyone with a pulse.
Anyone who has been on the losing end of America's dysfunctional and discriminatory health care system would support reform, right? (Even my wife and I have been burned by our insurance company, even though our age and good health supposedly make us the industry's most desirable customers.)
Unfortunately, reform has not come easily . The political rhetoric surrounding this issue has been the most vitriolic and, dare I say, uninformed of any issue I can recall (then again, I was thankfully not alive during Sen. Joseph McCarthy's tenure).
Which is why I, like most folks, will just be glad if Congress passes something -- anything -- and all the talk fades out in time for us to enjoy Christmas morning.
But what concerns me most about this whole situation is that the driving force behind the debate (at least among the general public) has not been facts, reason or civil discourse. Instead, the motive has largely been fear. Most Americans acknowledge there is a problem with our health care status quo, yet the arguments of those who oppose reforming it seem to boil down to fear -- fear that we might not do it perfectly, fear that it might cost money, fear that it would force us to rethink some things.
But the most consistent and obvious fear has been this: If we allow reform to pass, it would cede power to the "other" political party, and that would surely cement America's long and perilous slide into ruin because "those people" think differently than we do.
What is so sad is how much we Christians have bought into such fears.
Beloved, we in the Church have put far too much stock in politics. If we truly believe that one civic leader or another has our destiny in his or her hands, then we have tragically lost sight of the transcendence of God. He is ultimately in charge, not democracy or its mechanisms.
We must not forget this: As Christians, we know who wins in the end! So I am compelled to believe that whether health care reform is passed perfectly or botched splendidly, I will still be able to trust in the God who keeps his promises to watch over us and keep us.
That is the root of faith, is it not? And that also means that I refuse to pay any attention to politicians, radio talk jocks, self-described entertainers, and anyone else when they are more interested in getting reactions and consolidating their reputations than they are about seeking the truth.
In the health care debate, reform proponents have worked tirelessly to craft solutions to the problem, imperfect though they may be. Opponents have done little but retort with fiery speeches, occasional lies, and tired political cliches about "big government" and "small government." Though some criticisms leveled against reform are certainly valid, few if any legitimate alternatives have been proposed.
This should not be a politicized, right-versus-left fight, but it has sadly been reduced to that. It's hard to imagine how anyone could favor inaction at all costs, especially when lives are quite literally at stake.
So this Christmas, as organizations like the one where I work seek funds to provide health care to thousands of sick and dying people in poor nations, let's hope that millions of sick and dying people in the world's most powerful country can hope for the same.
And let us Christians, who should know the power of Christmas better than anyone, refuse to have anything to do with the politics of fear.
















































